While I was happy with my choice I kept reading reviews and watching youtube videos of all these other great foundation brands so I tried some others...and returned some others...this just taught me that reviews are a good place to start but it always comes down to what works for YOU! I tried revlon color stay mousse in the shade sand beige and I think it may have oxidized on my skin because after a few minutes of wearing it, it looked more pink/orangey than I thought. This may have been the result of adding my bronzer and illuminator as well and the colors just didn't blend well.
I also tried (and returned) revlon photo ready in the color nude. I totally thought this was going to work based on some google searching to match my color but again it was too orange for me. My friend suggested I go to MAC or Sephora and get matched for my foundation color to stop this madness. That's tip number 2: go to the MAC store and ask them to match you to a foundation! I found this to be super helpful and found I was the color NC25 in MAC Studio tech foundation. One day when I leave my cheap drugstore ways behind, I'm buying that! The big thing we noticed at MAC is my face has some redness and that can make it look pink but my body is clearly more yellow so we went with a yellow based foundation because it's important that your face matches your body. That's tip number 3, match your body. Side note: NC 25 may very likely be my summer shade as I'm a little tan so I may go and get re-matched in the winter to see what happens.
Ok so now you know what color you are in MAC...how does that help with buying other brands? Apparently the internet is full of people who wear MAC and has lots of information about if you wear this color in MAC, then you may be this color in another brand! Cool eh? Here's a fun website that I can't guarantee results but it's worth a try.
I used this website to see what color I was in the Loreal true match lumi that I already knew I loved and it just put me one shade darker from what I picked originally still in the neutral category (the name is natural buff). Here I am wearing it and look how it matches my body as I hold up my arm. (note: don't actually match your foundation to your arm...the photo was just to show you how it looks against my body. I have heard matching to your chest is good but I'm still figuring it out...this is why I went to MAC and let them find my match.)
I do still like this foundation in the lighter shade that I have and will likely be wearing that in the winter as my small tan fades. I think the name is classic ivory or something like that but it's the lightest in the neutral series. Here are my two shades...at least I hope I am doing it right now! (I guess I should add that there are also people all over the internet who say MAC did not match them correctly but the person I had tried multiple shades on me and asked what I thought as well as her opinion so hopefully you get someone good!)